Fixed Price or Time & Materials: Tradeoffs and Considertaions
INSIGHTS/
vendors and contracts

Fixed Price or Time & Materials: Tradeoffs and Considertaions

Clarke Schroeder
vendors and contracts

Fixed price sounds safe. There may be a catch.

In custom software, fixed price and time-and-materials (T&M) contracts both have value. The wrong contract creates friction, delays, and surprise costs.

A contract is not just about money. It shapes behavior, scope, and decision-making.

Fixed Price vs Time and Materials

Fixed Price

Fixed price means a set scope for a set cost.

Strengths:

  • Budget certainty upfront
  • Clear scope boundaries

Risks:

  • Changes trigger change orders and delays
  • Vendors may pad estimates to cover risk
  • Teams may optimize for contract, not outcome

Time and Materials (T&M)

T&M means paying for the real hours and effort used.

Strengths:

  • Flexibility to change priorities
  • Better fit when requirements evolve

Risks:

  • Cost can rise if scope grows
  • Requires strong transparency and management

The P.A.C.T. Framework

Use P.A.C.T. to pick the right contract model:

  • P . Project clarity: Are requirements stable and clear?
  • A . Adaptability: Will priorities change during development?
  • C . Cost certainty: Is a fixed budget more important than flexibility?
  • T . Trust: Is there enough transparency to run T&M well?

Mini Case Study. Agriculture Compliance Change

Problem: An agricultural supplier needed a custom inventory and traceability system.

Mistake: The project used a fixed-price contract with a tight scope. Midway through, new compliance rules required added traceability fields and reporting. The contract treated this as out-of-scope, triggering a change order and a timeline shift.

Fix: The supplier moved to a phased delivery model using T&M for the next stage, with a clear weekly plan, budget guardrails, and a change tradeoff rule.

Result: The team adjusted quickly to regulatory changes without stopping delivery. The system launched in smaller pieces, and the business stayed compliant.

Quick Takeaways

  • Fixed price buys cost certainty, but reduces flexibility.
  • T&M buys flexibility, but needs active budget control.
  • Contract choice depends on clarity, change, and trust.
  • Good project management matters more than contract type.

Score your project using P.A.C.T., then choose the contract that matches your real level of uncertainty.